The Woman on the Roof

Review of The Roof Beneath Their Feet; Geetanjali Shree; translated by Rahul Soni; Rs 299; pp 156

– Shana Susan Ninan

On the first glance, the title was oxymoronic – don’t we always talk about the roof above our heads? But here, the roof plays two different roles – one that stifles people inside it, and one that’s liberating when people are on it. In the author’s words, “a story is not necessarily ‘told’, it is ‘experienced’. People’s past and memories are reconstructed and rearranged, things left out, added on.

In her novels, Geetanjali Shree brings forward conversations and narrations that deal with people’s past and memories, the idea of physical space, and of course, strong women characters. In The Roof Beneath Their Feet, memories take a tactile form, weaving in and out of the readers’ minds. Strong and memorable metaphors, the roof being the most used and the most significant one, are a signature of the author. Lalna, one of the protagonists, is compared to the stories that wander the roof: carefree and unrestrained. Lalna belongs to no home nor hearth, but to the roof. A place where she can be herself.

The roof represents freedom and uninhibited expression of the freedom – people gather together for hanging clothes, flying kites, meeting clandestinely, and to generally chill out. The roof is an extension of their minds. For Chhacho and Lalna, the friendship that forms between them takes shape on the roof, at night, when the rest of the mohalla have slept. They sneak up to watch the sky, to let their hair down, to leave their goonghats on the parapets, to lift their blouses and fan themselves in the horrid heat, to… and many things that women are usually forbidden from.

After Chhacho’s death, her nephew and Lalna piece together their memories of her, amid the chaotic households that surround them. In real life, too, it’s often after a person’s death we put together our thoughts and memories of them, trying to figure out how and why they shaped our lives.

The book is special for me for three reasons – it was gifted by a close friend; the book’s cover photo was shot by my husband’s uncle and famous photographer Saibal Das; a one-line review of the book in one of the inside pages is written by a professor who taught me in CIEFL!

VN:F [1.9.20_1166]
Rating: 9.7/10 (3 votes cast)
The Woman on the Roof, 9.7 out of 10 based on 3 ratings

enjoyed this post? share with others:

twitter stumble upon digg

This entry was posted on Wednesday, June 18th, 2014 at 4:09 pm and is filed under Fiction, Reviews. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.


  1. July 11th, 2014 | Sanjiv Nair says:

    Respected Ms Shana Susan Ninan,

    Your academic spoils are impressive and you’re an
    Excellent reviewer of books. Your website is captivating
    mostly for its professional grasp. I like it and also
    appreciate your wonderful efforts for creating a literary
    sensibility and keeping it afloat.

    I recently wrote a novel ‘PURPOSE OF LOVE’ – a poignant
    story of a victim of rape. I frankly admit that my editor (not blaming her) left some 50 errors and I got them corrected and the reprints of the book would be fine. Though the mistakes were minor but it should not have occured at all. However, the novel is written with a revolutionary pitch and it is motivational too. It also sensitively shares the emotions of a victim of rape. I started to write vigorously to express my anguish after the horrible rape incident of December 2012. I’ve used a variety of elements to push on the narrative and it is written on a flash back mode. There is a stage when the novel assumes the form of a thriller. Since I wanted the young minds to read this I deliberately kept the content on the edge where the readers of all age groups could read the book for self-awareness. The theme behind the narrative is – “Don’t spoil a thing or harm a human being that you love dearly’. Whatever you love should get your trust, respect, responsibility, honesty, compassion, and faith.

    I will send you a few pages from the book for your kind consideration. You will find the blurb and about the author on my website : http://www.sanjivnair.com. I will send a PDF file. There is a story too ‘The Begging Bowl’ that you would like – the stories are from my collection ‘Face of guilt & other stories.

    With warm regards,
    Sanjiv Nair

leave a comment